Sierra Club reports on big fossil fuel's coordinated attack on clean energy

Sierra Club has dug up the money trail connecting fossil fuel companies funding with current legislative attempts to block renewable energy such as solar and wind. And there's our old friend ALEC!

Sierra Club PR today, “Clean Energy Under Siege” Study Follows Money Trail Behind Campaign Against Renewable Energy

If well-funded opponents of clean energy are willing to commit resources to hurting their enemies at the federal level, it only follows that they would pursue their goals in state and local venues as well.

FIGURE 1 — TOP 10 OIL & GAS LOBBYING COMPANIES, 2011

Client/Parent	Total
ConocoPhillips	$20,557,043
Royal Dutch Shell	$14,790,000
Exxon Mobil	$12,730,000
Chevron Corp.	$9,510,000

State Renewable Portfolio Standards have long been regarded as a major driver for the addition of renewable energy generation. RPS's have been established in some form in 30 states and generally require a utility to produce an increasing percentage of the electricity they sell from renewable sources. Wind energy has been a particular beneficiary of state RPS laws and has also helped lower the overall cost of electricity in many of those states.

Groups like the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) are a clear and present threat to state RPS laws. ALEC describes itself as a nonprofit group that “works to advance the fundamental principles of free-market enterprise, limited government, and federalism at the state level....”23 ALEC's modus operandi is to provide state lawmakers with “model legislation” that will carry out the goals of its corporate members.

They have had significant success with several initiatives. One high-profile example is the “stand your ground” law — ALEC-authored legislation that was implemented nearly word-for-word across several states.

Let's not forget Georgia's HB 87 "anti-immigration" law, based on a model bill that ALEC-affiliated legislators proposed in at least 24 states. A law that actually creates new misdemeanors and felonies that feed the private prison industry, such as Corrections Corporation of America (CCA), which tried to build a private prison in Lowndes County, Georgia.

ALEC is also pushing a charter school law that the Georgia legislature passed that put a referendum on November's ballot to authorize Atlanta overriding local school boards. Privatizing schools would do no more to improve education than privatizing prisons has done to improve incarceration. It's all about fiddling laws for the profit of ALEC's cronies.

Today, ALEC is in the process of approving anti-RPS language to send to willing sponsors in state Houses across the nation.

Here's the gist of the whole thing:

It is a testament to the success and rapid growth of clean-energy resources that they are now regarded as enough of a threat to draw fire from some of the largest, most powerful corporations on the planet.

Those would be the corporations that are making historic record profits by

spewing fossil fuel smoke into our air and by fracking pollutants into our groundwater. Yes, they are a tad miffed to see Moore's Law lofting solar over their heads and wind now competitive on price with nuclear, coal, and gas. And they probably don't like their money trail being exposed.

Sierra Club has succeeded in annoying Institute for Energy Research (IER), which issued a weak three-point rebuttal, the first point of which confuses "vested economic interests that fund their operations and predetermine their conclusions" with "government sources". Maybe IER has a reading comprehension problem? The point is that regulatory capture by big oil and big gas and big nuclear is not a free market. IER's "rebuttal" doesn't actually rebut any of the main assertions in Sierra Club's report, for example, IER doesn't deny its ties to ALEC.

Who else has ties to ALEC? Apparently Southern Company, largest electric utility in the country and sixth largest in the world.

Certainly few companies have worked as hard to prevent renewable energy throughout the southeast as Southern Company has, while actively promoting bet-the-farm nuclear, "21st century coal", and natural gas through fracking. Notice how that big southeast gap in the map of renewable energy standards surrounds Southern Company's service territory. That could be coincidence, but continued efforts by Southern Company and its child corporation Georgia Power to stymie renewable energy indicate the lack of REPs hereabouts is not coincidental.

You can help Sierra Club expose ALEC and its cronies. And you can help convince corporations to dump ALEC, by signing one of many petitions, or by writing directly to affiliated corporations, such as Southern Company.

-jsq

Comments

[Todd Wynn]

Although the Sierra Club was notified of the errors in their report, they have yet to address them. In addition, neither fact checking nor communication was attempted by the Sierra Club on claims made in this report.

In response to this error-filled report , here is a short statement and brief fact check.
http://www.alec.org/fact-setting-response-to-sierra-club-report/