On the LAKE Front

Our honest responses to HUD —George Rhynes and John Robinson

Received today. -jsq

September 26, 2012 George Boston Rhynes 5004 Oak Street Valdosta, Georgia 31605

TO:

U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Valdosta City Government Valdosta Housing Authority Valdosta Industrial Authority

The following is our honest responses to HUD and in response to the City of Valdosta's 8th Year of responding to HUD CPMP Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report. This includes Narrative Responses to CAPER questions in relations to and with the Consolidated Planning Regulations and questions from the general public as highlighted on page 5, paragraph 1.

---

CITIZENS VIEW POINT AND RESPONSES: {GEORGE BOSTON RHYNES AND JOHN ROBNISON} after reviewing all previous CAPTER'S and the city's responses to them, I commend the City of Valdosta for responding to HUD in an extremely professional manner on paper. One can see and feel the professional prowess involved in providing these answers the City of Valdosta has placed on paper over the city's (long) historic past. However, when one looks deeper into the problems facing our beloved community, one will find the following to be as Paul Harvey would say the rest of——-the story!

GENERAL QUESTIONS: The City of Valdosta's response on the issues remains the same as reported in many other CAPERS such as:

• City attained the goal of:
• # of homes was brought up to code.
• Worked in conjunction with——
• to train, resident information sessions were held that yielded nearly 30 attendees etc.
• Staff continues to...., Overall, the city is pleased with the second Consolidated Plan Submission.
• (3.a) The city hosted several Section 3 Information Sessions and will continue to provide more information to.... Work with local community and faith-based organizations to identify and address.
• I could go on and on with these highly professional lines of what some see as solutions to the real problems in the City of Valdosta, Georgia. However there is another side and forgive me for not going through the complete CAPER in the above manner. I am sure your time is valuable; therefore I will cut through the chase and provide the following in response to the City of Valdosta RESPONSES. Not only to this CAPER but others we have read and taken into consideration:

A recent meeting held in the Valdosta City Annex about Community Housing etc. perhaps exemplifies

There is something you can do

Anybody who has tried to do much of anything around here has run into this phrase:

There's nothing you can do.

I was reminded of that when I read this, from the Economist 12 May 2012, Hope springs a trap,

This hopelessness manifests itself in many ways. One is a sort of pathological conservatism, where people forgo even feasible things with potentially large benefits for fear of losing the little they already possess.

The article expands on that idea:

Development economists have long surmised that some very poor people may remain trapped in poverty because even the largest investments they are able to make, whether eating a few more calories or working a bit harder on their minuscule businesses, are too small to make a big difference. So getting out of poverty seems to require a quantum leap—vastly more food, a modern machine, or an employee to mind the shop. As a result, they often forgo even the small incremental investments of which they are capable: a bit more fertiliser, some more schooling or a small amount of saving.

It may seem that the article is about the poorest of people, but that "pathological conservatism" could as easily apply to the hopelessness many people seem to have about ever getting solar panels on their own roofs, or to attracting enough business to our area to employ our high school and college graduates, or that businesses will ever come to the south side.

Yet the point of the article is that field studies by MIT economist Esther Duflo show

Ahead of schedule, under budget, and same officers again: Video Playlist @ VLCIA 2012-06-19

The Industrial Authority board at their 19 June 2012 meeting decided to renominate the same officers for another term at the 19 June 2012 Industrial Authority meeting. All their business park projects are ahead of schedule and under budget, although it seems odd to be cutting down trees to detain water. They're under budget for the entire year, and next year's budget is less than that for the the fiscal year just being completed. They have hired a website contractor, and they've already made extensive changes to their Valdosta Prospector website. The 100% VSEB native grass landscaping project is underway.

They meet again tonight.

Here's the agenda. A few notes below on a few specific videos from last month's meeting.

• CPA Tom Davis expected VLCIA will end the fiscal year underbudget $100,000. He said the county told him collections remain flat. (The county's version of that at its own budget hearing was a bit more complicated.)
• Jerry Jennett said the proposed new budget included $31,000 less in general operations, clarified expenditures for example in business retention and expansion, and the total was about $906,000, down from $916,000 for the previous fiscal year. Maybe soon we the taxpayers will get to see this budget that they approved at that meeting a month ago.
• S. Meghan Duke said they had selected Marketing Alliance to update their website and they'd be meeting in July for "a creative brief and a site map". She said it would go fast, although once again she didn't actually say when she expected it would be visible on the web. And they'd updated all their other websites, Georgia EMC, Select Georgia, Location Georgia, and Valdosta Prospector. Plus they were developing economic development presentations that officials throughout the county could use, on industrial sites, retail and restaurants, etc.
• She gave a lengthy presentation of the GIS website Valdosta-Lowndes Prospector.
• Allan Ricketts said four local businesses were discussing expanding, and VLCIA was considering rebranding its business retention and expansion tools.
• Somebody sent some requests for information regarding an airport project. VLCIA continues to discuss a food distribution project. Miller Business Park development continues "nice trees," a "cadillac of a park". They're considering an open house soon.
• Miller Business Park work is mostly finished, including that related to DuPont. The 100% VSEB native grass landscaping project is underway.
• Rickets said they were cutting down large trees for stormwater detention at Lake Park Business Park. Does that seem right to you?
• He said they were ahead of schedule and under budget on all three business parks they were working on.
• Robert Beardon wants a change to his land contract.
• The nominating committee asked the entire current slate of officers to serve another term and they all said yes: Chairman Roy Copeland, Vice-Chairman Mary Gooding, and Secretary-Treasurer Norman Bennett. Roy Copeland proposed changing the official term length to two years. Attorney Gupton pointed out terms of board members were odd lengths, so one could roll off the board before a two year officer term was up. Jerry Jennett said he'd looked at the enabling legislation (presumably the Valdosta-Lowndes County Industrial Authority Act) and he thought it meant officers were elected every year. Copeland accepted that point, and they voted to accept that slate. They actually elect officers at their next meeting (today). (I'm glad they're reading their own charter these days, and I no longer have to read it to them.)
• One citizen was heard (me), who congratulated them on organizing the focus group which I was to attend the next day. I congratulated them further afterwards in a letter to the editor of the local newspaper of record. Maybe tonight we'll hear some report back about the focus groups.
• They adjourned into an executive session for the purpose of future acquisition of real property.

Here's a video playlist:

Video Playlist
Regular Meeting, Valdosta-Lowndes County Industrial Authority (VLCIA),
Norman Bennett, Tom Call, Roy Copeland chairman, Mary Gooding, Jerry Jennett, Andrea Schruijer Executive Director, J. Stephen Gupton Attorney, Tom Davis CPA, Allan Ricketts Project ManagerS. Meghan Duke Public Relations & Marketing Manager, Lu Williams, Operations Manager,
Videos by John S. Quarterman for Lowndes Area Knowledge Exchange (LAKE), Valdosta, Lowndes County, Georgia, 19 June 2012.

-jsq

Local grass and 100% VSEB local contractors for landscaping Westside Business Park @ VLCIA 2012-05-22

The very first 100% VSEB contract! In a welcome change of pace, Allan Ricketts announced at the 22 May 2012 Industrial Authority meeting that staff had accepted a proposal to have local conctractors plant native local grasses as part of landscaping Westside Business Park.

VSEB is the Valdosta Small Emerging Business program. He identified the grass as Little Bluefield. Later he said that was the same as Little Bluestem, which is a well known native warm season bunchgrass (Schizachyrium scoparium).

Here's the video:

Local grass and 100% VSEB local contractors for landscaping Westside Business Park
Regular Meeting, Valdosta-Lowndes County Industrial Authority (VLCIA),
Norman Bennett, Tom Call, Roy Copeland chairman, Mary Gooding, Jerry Jennett,
Andrea Schruijer Executive Director, J. Stephen Gupton attorney, Allan Ricketts Project Manager, Tom Davis, CPA, Lu Williams, Operations Manager, S. Meghan Duke, Public Relations & Marketing Manager,
Valdosta, Lowndes County, Georgia, 22 May 2012.
Video by John S. Quarterman for Lowndes Area Knowledge Exchange (LAKE).

-jsq

Videos @ ZBOA 2012 03 06

The Valdosta-Lowndes County Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBOA) had a somewhat unusual case to start out its March meeting, of someone wanting to revert to a previous zoning after the County Commission had approved a rezoning. The owner wants to do a development, but doesn't have the resources in this economy, so wants to go back to agricultural zoning to make a little money while waiting. It was complicated, with issues of wetlands, costs, advice by county staff, and small business employment. Watch and see!

View Larger Map

They also had a sign request from Denny's, with input from the neighboring Mobil station and others.

Both of these cases were numbered 2012-01 (one from the county and one from the city). How can they be numbered 01? If I understand correctly, these were the first cases ZBOA has received this year, and this was the first ZBOA meeting this year. That could be an indication of the state of the local economy.

ZBOA mostly considers

VSEB application is too long — John Robinson @ VCC 2012 02 23

John Robinson told the Valdosta City Council that he thought the application for the Valdosta Small Emerging Business (VSEB) Program was too long and complicated compared to the one-page application to do major construction work.

Here's the video:

VSEB application is too long — John Robinson @ VCC 2012 02 23
VSEB, employment,
Regular Session, Valdosta City Council (VCC),
Valdosta, Lowndes County, Georgia, 23 February 2012.
Videos by George Boston Rhynes for K.V.C.I., the bostongbr on YouTube.

-jsq

An Industrial Authority agenda with content! Including VSEB and land acreage!

Yesterday Andrea Schruijer promised to get an agenda for tomorrow's 2PM Thursday 23 February 2012 Industrial Authority board meeting (101 N. Ashley Street) online. It's there, and it has content! What it does not have is any mention of anything about Project Excel, or CCA, or the private prison, even though Ms. Schruijer told me yesterday to expect the board to say something about that. You can still express your opinion to them before then. And since this agenda says **TENTATIVE** maybe that item will get added before tomorrow afternoon.

Also missing is any item for the Strategic Planning RFP, even though that RFP says the board will review any responses received by their February board meeting.

What this agenda does have is numerous specific items under the usual broad headers such as Existing Industry/Project Report. So instead of listening to Col. Ricketts and trying to figure out what he's talking about, you can see such things as "e-Snychronist® Existing Industry Retention and Expansion business information system (BIS)" in writing. You still don't see names of the "five (5) Prospects" or the "three (3) companies that are developing expansion plans". Maybe I buy the competitive information argument for the prospects, but I'm not so sure about the three expanding companies, especially if they're already local. And considering the things VLCIA has tried to sneak in under cover of not mentioning competitive information, such as biomass and a private prison, I'm not sure I buy that argument at all.

Also on the plus side, the agenda includes an actual schedule for bids

Small emerging businesses —Mr. Robinson @ VLCIA 19 July 2011

John Robinson congratulated Roy Copeland for accepting the position as chair of the Valdosta-Lowndes County Industrial Authority (VLCIA) and said:

We're looking forward to working along with you guys, because we truly need the help now on the other side of the railroad track over there.
...
And we do believe that if everyone try to work together we can get something done.

Update: What the VDT said:

Received a thank you from John Robinson of the Black Businessmen’s Association during the Citizens to be Heard portion of the meeting for agreeing to work with small and emerging businesses, with the goal of removing the “social divide” in the city;

Here's the video:

Small emerging businesses —Mr. Robinson @ VLCIA 19 July 2011
Regular Meeting, Valdosta-Lowndes County Industrial Authority (VLCIA),
Norman Bennett, Tom Call, Roy Copeland chairman, Mary Gooding, Jerry Jennett,
Andrea Schruijer Executive Director, J. Stephen Gupton attorney, Allan Ricketts Project Manager,
Valdosta, Lowndes County, Georgia, 19 July 2011.
Videos by John S. Quarterman for LAKE, the Lowndes Area Knowledge Exchange.

-jsq

Economic opportunity and cooperation —John Robinson @ VCC 9 June 2011

Discussing the VSEB program, John Robinson remarked:

We need the council up here to show us interest in this program.

He recommended everybody work together, including city and county.

Here's the video:

Economic opportunity and cooperation —John Robinson @ VCC 9 June 2011
Regular Meeting, Valdosta City Council (VCC),
Valdosta, Lowndes County, Georgia, 4 June 2011.
Videos by Barbara Stratton for LAKE, the Lowndes Area Knowledge Exchange.

-jsq

How to get public officials to respond to the citizens?

Leigh Touchton asked me,

Mr. Quarterman, what can we do, do we have to go to the state legislature to get a law passed to force these so-called public officials to answer questions and respond to the citizens?

First of all, my compliments to anyone such as Leigh Touchton who has been doing politics around here longer than me for asking my opinion, because that indicates they are pretty good at it and are probably asking many people their opinions.

My answer: carrots along with sticks, and shine some light! That all builds political capital, which will be needed for elections.

We need many people building a community doing many things. If I knew a simple answer that would change things magically overnight, I'd recommend it, but I don't. I don't even know if I know a long answer, but I'm pretty sure that any answer will require a community, because